Bosses wrongly think women have more problems at work

Posted at 4:27 PM Nov 10, 2009

By Andrea Grimes

workinggirlposter.jpg
You'd think a look into the personal and public lives of male politicians would prove this to anyone with a brain, but apparently stereotypes stick: bosses believe men have fewer problems balancing their home and work lives ... even though they don't, actually. In fact, women are likely to report less family-work conflict than men. According to Reuters:

Women's careers are being stymied by more than a glass ceiling. Bosses believe women have more family-work conflict, which is a misconception that is holding them back, according to new research. And it's not just male managers who have the wrong idea. "These perceptual biases held for both male and female managers," Jenny Hoobler, of the University of Illinois at Chicago, and her co-authors said.
Love it--even though something isn't actually true, a societal fear of women's power and autonomy still makes it kind of true--at least in terms of the negative effects on women's real lives. (See: suffrage, reproductive rights, etc.)


The Chicago study asked 178 managers and subordinates about how women handle their private and professional lives, and strangely, the more women were dedicated to managing these things (by being part of organizations and programs dedicated to just that), the more they were seen as being unable to handle their (often) double days:

"The women's movement of the 60s and 70s in the United States brought revolutionary change in terms of women's upward progress in organizations, but the biases supporting the glass ceiling today are much more subtle, multifaceted and deeply embedded than they were then," the researchers said. "Today women encounter biases so rooted in systems that they may not even be noticed until they are eradicated. In this study, we believe we have identified one such bias," they added.

Again, here we see that even women have internalized the idea that to be male, and to have a male experience, is the default and that any variation on that is negative. I personally love the idea that women may still have more work to do--again, with the double day--but are completely able to handle it.

Then again, we may be looking at a case of another common phenomenon: the fact that women are not supposed to complain about things that stress or upset them, lest they be seen as shrill, bitchy or unladylike. If the false perception about women's inability to handle work stresses really does widely exist apart from a 178-person study, women in the workplace who know about it are probably still unlikely to address it, lest their situation get even shittier.

Comments

Jen Dalitz said:

I've seen unconscious gender bias in place on so many occasions that I see this as a much more important issue to tackle than glass ceilings. Why in talent and succession planning meetings do people leaders still discuss a woman's marital status and whether she has kids (or is likely to have them) as an indication of her flight risk? (yes, it really does happen) Why are men usually described by their people leaders in these discussions in terms of their competency attributes (the sorts of projects and work he's undertaken of past), whereas women are described to those not familiar with them in terms of their physical attributes (what she looks like). Why do we still assume that leadership roles cannot be performed on flexible terms (when all the technology has long existed for work to be performed and monitored remotely and on flexible terms). These are all examples of unconscious bias that I've seen in play time and time again. They perpetuate the stereotype that leaders are male, that their life revolves around their work and that the old way is the only way. We need to bring examples of bias and stereotypes out into the open and give women the confidence of knowing they're not alone in experiencing these issues - this will give women the confidence and energy to keep pushing on when they're faced with such obstacles. www.sphinxx.com.au

© 2012 Village Voice Media Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved.